Showing posts with label Website. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Website. Show all posts

Thursday, April 12, 2007

Search: Much Is Lacking


Search as is is not good enough. If you can't find what you are looking for, as often happens. The user is not in control enough.

Search is especially poor on the multimedia front. You have to find a particular site, and then search around inside that site, often you have to be a registered user to make use of the stuff offering.

There is no one place where you can go to search through all photos online, no one place to look for audio and video clips, all of them, no way you can zero in like you might zero in onto a map, zoom in, zoom out.

It would be nice to be able to zero in on content providers based on their geographical location. That would really help.

There is not enough standardization. All of the web is not being shown as one search space. Participating sites would benefit. If you make it easier for users to find you, that is good business, right?

Ad offerings will have to get creative if the ad model is to be the primary revenue generator. Tiny ads. This photo brought to you by Coke. Can you say that in an inch in length, and 1/10th that in width, maybe in less? Of course, you can see the Coke logo which, if you click on takes you to the Coke website, perhaps.

Multimedia search as it stands is primitive.
  1. Make it super easy for users to create and store media.
  2. Make it super easy for users to find media.
  3. Make it super easy for users to share and consume media, to display media on their own sites.
So the emphasis has to be on standardization of search so as to make it as easy as possible for search to happen. Maybe content providers and search engines should actively collaborate to that end. And the way to maximize sharing is to rely on the ad model. The average user wishes to be able to display for "free." And that is where the big money is, in the "free" zone.

Say if I took a photo, and uploaded it at some photo sharing site like Flickr, and I had the option to let just about anyone to display that image, as long as I could have that little link ad, that maybe links back to my own site, I would be okay. What about you?

Revver has a pretty good model for video.

Textbooks are game. Textbooks also have to be offered like media. Ad supported. Maybe disable copy and paste, at the author's discretion.

The average web user is going to want to produce content. Right now search is chaos. What is the GPS version of web search?

Advanced search options need to get much more intuitive.

Google is huge. It is an elephant. As it grows bigger, it is going to get less nimble. That will create huge markets for niche search. One size will not fit all.

Redefine search.

What am I looking for? How long does it take me to find it?



Some combination of machine search and social search might also work, especially when the end user is in control as to the degree of it.

It is to Google's advantage that it also provides platforms for content creation, like Blogger.

Just like it does with text, a good search engine should be able to help you search through multimedia without the multimedia sites actively collaborating. Multimedia sites should get indexed as they spring up, and they could spring up anywhere, any part of the globe.

Multimedia in English has been problem enough. The problem is compounded when you demand - as you should - that the multimedia search has to be language neutral. The machine should be able to understand any media in any language and offer it to you in your language of choice. That has to be the goal.

But first search has to get language neutral for text. Multimedia will be step two.

What if you are not necessarily looking for the most popular and most linked to and most visited sites to show up at the top. Some of the best sites for what you are looking for might be on page 350 or worse. How will you ever find them?

The advanced search option is not advanced enough, and it should not be a separate page where you basically have to fill out a form, it should be as intuitive as simple search. You tweak a few things here and there and you are ready to go.

Also how do you make it easy for people to do mashups and still not destroy the ad business model? How do you make RSS stuff really simple, as the name promises but has not delivered?

Create content. Consume content. The netizen demands those two basic functions.

And my pet peeve of all: why can't you "blog" in mathematical symbols? Like you can find chess players to play chess with at Yahoo Games, you should be able to collaborate on mathematical work. Just do a search and find them.

What does the netizen want? That will be a perennial question. It will still be asked a hundred years from now.

Remember that adage from the last dot com bust, that a site is all page hits and no revenue? Looks like page hits are all that matter after all. It was not a bad business model to start with. Just a little too early.

A Web 3.0 Manifesto
Dell, HP, Apple
Google Books: Primitive
The Next Search Engine
Memo To Bill Gates
Google And Languages
Internet Phones, Video Blogging, Nano
Google: Poised To Be The Number One Software Company In The World

Reblog this post [with Zemanta]

Wednesday, July 19, 2006

The Next Search Engine


It might as well be Google itself, but there sure is a lot of room for search. The amount of data available online is just going to keep growing like crazy. Five of the six billion people are not yet online. And as they come online, companies are going to work to make it easier and easier for people to create data online, text, audio, video and more. So you are looking at more and more stuff, in more and more languages, in more and more formats, text, audio,video. And there is the perennial demand: the quality of search. Can you find what you are looking for? How precise is the result? How user friendly is the search experience?

Google's handicap for now is it only knows text. And even text it does not do as well as we might want, even though it does it better than anyone else.

When you search for something you want the most relevant webpages and sites to show up first. And you want to be able to search within sites. How to rank pages? Google started out by saying the more sites that link to your site, the more valuable it is. Well, maybe, but not if many of them are link farms. But that was a great way to start. That still has to be the basic formula. But then each site has to be given a weight of its own based on many different criteria.



The language challenge is a big one, as is the format challenge. Can a search engine "read" audio and video like it reads words? Can a search engine search content regardless of what language or format it might be in, and then present the same in the language of the end user's choosing? You are talking real time translation. That right there is a huge challenge. Major work will have to be done in speech software to make this possible.

The formula that a website's worth is how many other websites link to it is basically good. But the formula has to get more sophisticated than that. Not all links are equal. And each site should have a weight based on a few different things. So one link from a really good site should count for more than many links from so so sites. And the search engine should be able to count the page hits for each site in real time. The activity level of a site should be a major factor of how important a site is. As important as links.

And there is this real time thing. Say if I put out a new website or just a new page to an existing site, how long before the search engine finds it? Can it be an hour? A minute? Less? It should be less than a second. The reverse should also be true. If a site or a page is taken down, the search engine should know.

Language, content format, speech, website weightage based on links and page hits. These are some of the things that come to mind. This is enough homework for now.

Google might or might not deliver. There is plenty of room for others, especially for bold upstarts.

Eric Schmidt interview (39mins MP3)



Kosmix: Desi Pride
Email, Search, News
Memo To Bill Gates

On The Web

Search engine - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Google UK
AltaVista
MSN Search
Google
A9.com Home Page
Dogpile Web Search Home Page
Homepage HotBot Web Search
Web Site Search Engine, Free and Pro Versions - FreeFind.com
Yahoo!
Ask.com Search Engine - Better Web Search
MetaCrawler Web Search Home Page - MetaCrawler
Yahoo! Search - Web Search
Vivisimo Clustering Engine
Yahooligans
Search Engine Watch
altavista.digital.com/
Google
My Excite
AllTheWeb
WebCrawler Web Search Home Page
Google Scholar
Ixquick
Ask.com Search Engine - Better Web Search
Lycos
Scirus
KartOO visual meta search engine
Go
Environment Web Directory
go2: The #1 Yellow Pages on your mobile phone
ProFusion - The Original Meta-Search Engine
KidsClick! Web Search
Lucene Search Engine
Clusty the Clustering Engine
Google Blog Search
Gigablast
Netscape Search
PsychCrawler
WebSideStory Site Search and Web Content Management Applications
Ask for Kids
Creative Commons Search
Chemical Search Engine
Mamma Metasearch - The Mother of All Search Engines
Search engine optimization - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Google Australia
What is search engine? - A Word Definition From the Webopedia ...
Scrub The Web Search Engine
Find | Creative Commons
Kids' Tools for Searching the Internet
Search Engines
Search Engine Colossus
Search Engine Guide
Submit Express - Search Engine Placement, Optimization, SEO Marketing
CNN.com
W3 Search Engines XML
AudioFind.com - multimedia internet search
Clipart Searcher - find free clip art, photos, and animations
InFoPeople: Best Search Tools Chart
Search the RFC Index
SplatSearch.com: We do all the searching for you.
Arabic Search Engine: Directory of arabic and islamic sites
SEO Book
Beaucoup! 2000+ Search Engines, Indices and Directories
Koders - Source Code Search Engine
Main - TSEP - The Search Engine Project - A search engine for your ...
Fast Search
isoHunt - World's largest BitTorrent search engine
WiseNut
Yahoo! Search Marketing
Search Engines
Search Engine Lowdown
Bittorrent
mnoGoSearch - Internet search engine software
Blog Search Engine
Fluid Dynamics Search Engine
LookSmart Vertical Search
Search Engines :: Mozilla Add-ons :: Add Features to Mozilla Software
Search Engine Features Chart
Search Engine Showdown
Internet Search Engines
bruceclay.com - Search Engine Relationship Chart®
MathSearch -- search a collection of mathematical Web material
Search Engine Submission, Website Optimization and Free ...
FindLaw LawCrawler - Law, Lawyer, Lawyers. Attorney, Attorneys
AllSearchEngines.com
MIDI Search Engine: Let MIDI Explorer find your files
Debian GNU/Linux -- Search
Entrez cross-database search
InFind
SearchEngineWatch Forums -- Discussions About Search Engine ...
A Helpful Guide to Search Engines, Top Page
MSDS-Search
Blinkx
Rocketinfo - Search Result
Searching Stanford
Choose the Best Search for Your Information Need
Search Engine Decoder | Relationship Chart
Lyrics Search Engine
Web site search facilities - OHCHR
RootsWeb: Database Index
Ananzi Search Engine
Search Engine Roundtable
The Cybercafe Search Engine, July 17, 2006


Reblog this post [with Zemanta]